Comparing modernization firms
Legacy modernization firms for enterprise web apps, compared
To compare legacy modernization firms for enterprise web apps, check seven things on each firm's own website: whether it modernizes in increments while the old system runs, whether it assesses the code first, how it reduces risk, which web stacks it knows, where its engineers work, its security certification, and its case studies.
Updated
Disclosure: Briebug wrote this page and is one of the five firms compared.
Five firms, seven criteria
Each firm describes phased or incremental modernization of legacy applications on its own website. Firms are in alphabetical order. Every claim about another firm comes from that firm's own site, and its source is linked in the cell and quoted under Sources. "Not stated" means we did not find it on the firm's site on the date checked, not that the firm does not do it: ask the firm.
| Criterion | Briebug | Improving | Keyhole Software | Radixweb | Thoughtworks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Incremental approach | Yes. Old and new parts run side by side while the work moves through the system, with upgrades through supported versions, one step at a time. Its guide covers when to replace piece by piece (strangler fig). Source Source | Phased. Improving describes a phased, collaborative approach that minimizes disruption. Source | Incremental. It offers incremental modernization of legacy monoliths and outdated frameworks, and sequences the work so production stays stable. Source Source | Phased and incremental, bridging legacy and modern systems, with parallel environments for testing before go-live. Source | Incremental. Its manufacturing modernization page says it modernizes one capability at a time using the Strangler Fig pattern, with production live throughout. It describes a thin slice approach. Source Source |
| Assessment first | Yes. Briebug's fixed-fee Technical Assessment is $10K and takes about a week. Senior engineers review your code, architecture, process, pipeline and security. Source Source | A legacy assessment and roadmap is offered. A fixed fee is not stated. Source | An assessment and modernization roadmap is offered. A fixed fee is not stated. Source | Modernization readiness audits with risk evaluations are offered. A fixed fee is not stated. Source | Discovery exercises to pick which applications to modernize first. A fixed fee is not stated. Source |
| Risk reduction | Tests first, around the code that has to change. A release pipeline you can trust. Security gaps from the assessment closed as the code they live in is modernized. Source | Secure data migrations with full validation, and a DevOps foundation named in a case study. Source | Risk mitigation planning, and AI-generated code validated through automated tests, architectural review and controlled commits. Source | Security-first modernization, rollback options, and continuous CI/CD pipelines. Source | Continuous delivery expertise and evolutionary architecture. Source |
| Web stacks | Angular-focused, across several stacks: AngularJS to Angular, .NET Framework to modern .NET, and Java, React, Laravel, Ruby and Rails, Node and more. Source | Several stacks. It modernizes front-end experiences, and its case studies name React and Java. Source | Several stacks, including Java and .NET platforms and single-page applications. Source | Several stacks: .NET, Java, PHP and JavaScript. Source | Not stated |
| Delivery location | United States only. Every engineer on a client engagement is a US citizen or US person physically located in the US. No offshore subcontracting. Source | Offices in the US, Canada, Mexico, Central and South America, and India. Source | United States only. All consultants are full-time W-2 employees based in the U.S., with no subcontractors or offshore resources. Headquartered in Kansas City. Source | Offices in the USA and India. Source | 45 offices in 22 countries. Source |
| Security certification | All client code and data stays on US-based infrastructure. Preparing for SOC 2 (audit begins January 2027). Source Source | SOC 2 and ISO 27001, stated in its guide to nearshore partners. Source | Not stated | ISO 27001:2022 and ISO 9001:2015. Source | ISO 27001:2022, for all of its offices. Source |
| Modernization case studies | Yes. PSIA: Angular 7 to 17 and .NET Core 3.1 to .NET 8. Restore United: current Angular in an Nx monorepo, CI/CD into AWS. CenterStone: AngularJS modernization. Source Source Source | Yes. Boys Town National Research Hospital, a legacy C++ system replaced with a modern web application, and Berkshire Hathaway Energy, a legacy Java Swing app modernized with React. Source | Yes. Including a government agency's Java platform and single-page application, and a government cloud, .NET and React modernization. Source Source | Modernization case studies are listed, including a modernized solution for a health insurance firm. Source | Its legacy modernization page lists client stories, including Unieuro: understanding a legacy SAP commerce platform before modernization. Source |
Prices are left out: none of the other four firms publishes one for this work, so ask each for a written price.
How to choose a legacy modernization firm
Start from your own risk, not from a firm's size. Each criterion in the table is there because it changes how likely the work is to reach production without stopping the application the business runs on.
- Incremental approach: Changing the system piece by piece, with old and new running side by side, means no single cutover carries all the risk and the roadmap does not stop.
- Assessment first: A review before the plan finds what is out of support, where the business rules live and which parts cause the most trouble, which sets the order of the work.
- Risk reduction: Tests that record what the application does today, and a pipeline that can roll a release back, are what make each small step safe to ship.
- Web stacks: A firm that has moved your exact stack before, such as AngularJS to Angular or .NET Framework to modern .NET, knows the breaking changes before it meets them.
- Delivery location: Where the engineers work decides the meeting hours, and some regulated buyers restrict where their code may be handled.
- Security certification: A published certification shortens the vendor-risk review that an enterprise runs before any engineer sees the code.
- Modernization case studies: A case study that names the old and new stack shows the firm has done the work you need, not only work near it.
Which kind of firm fits
- A firm with an assessment step: Nobody can yet say what is out of support or where the business rules live, so any plan made without a review of the code would be a guess.
- A firm that works only in your own country: Your security team restricts where code may be handled, or the work needs daily meetings with your engineers.
- A firm with offices in several countries: You need a larger team or coverage across time zones, and your security review allows code to be handled outside your country.
- A large global consultancy: The web application is one part of a wider change across data, platforms and many teams, and you want one partner for all of it.
What to ask each firm
- Incremental approach: Will the old application keep serving users while you modernize it, and what is the first piece you would release?
- Assessment first: Will you review our code and architecture before you quote, for a fixed fee, and is the written report ours to keep?
- Risk reduction: What do you put in place before you change the code: tests, a release pipeline, rollback, security fixes?
- Web stacks: Which frameworks and runtimes have you modernized, from which version to which, and who on the team led that work?
- Delivery location: Where will the engineers on our project work, and in which time zone?
- Security certification: Which security certification do you hold, and can we see the certificate and its scope?
- Modernization case studies: Which legacy application did you modernize, from what to what, did it stay in production, and can we speak to that client?
Send every firm the same brief and the same questions, and compare the written answers.
Where Briebug fits
Briebug's column in the table links each answer to the page of this site that states it. Judge those answers the way you judge any other firm's, and ask for them in writing.
- Application modernization, step by step, while the application keeps working.
- How to modernize a legacy application without a full rewrite, the approach in detail.
- AngularJS to Angular and .NET end-of-life upgrades, the stacks buyers ask about most.
- The fixed-fee Technical Assessment, $10K, before any larger commitment.
Choosing for an Angular application? See Angular enterprise modernization partners compared.
Sources
The words on each firm's own website that support each claim in the table, with the date we read the page. We re-check these every quarter. If a firm's site has changed, tell us and we will correct the table.
Improving
- Incremental approach:
At Improving, we apply a phased, collaborative approach that minimizes disruption and maximizes long-term value.
https://www.improving.com/expertise/applications/legacy-modernization/, checked . - Assessment first:
Legacy Assessment & Roadmap
/We evaluate your current architecture, systems, and challenges to build a strategic modernization roadmap tailored to your business goals.
https://www.improving.com/expertise/applications/legacy-modernization/, checked . - Risk reduction:
execute secure, end-to-end data migrations with full validation and zero downtime
/established a sustainable DevOps foundation
https://www.improving.com/expertise/applications/legacy-modernization/, checked . - Web stacks:
We modernize front-end experiences
/modernize a legacy Java Swing app into a cloud-native, microservices-based system using React, Kafka, and Azure
https://www.improving.com/expertise/applications/legacy-modernization/, checked . - Delivery location:
Chicago, Illinois
/Calgary, Alberta
/Guadalajara
/Guatemala City, Guatemala
/Buenos Aires, Argentina
/Pune, India
https://www.improving.com/locations/, checked . - Security certification:
maintaining ISO 27001 and SOC 2 certifications
https://www.improving.com/thoughts/nearshore-software-development-services-partners/, checked . - Modernization case studies:
Boys Town National Research Hospital worked with Improving to replace a legacy C++ system with a modern web application for grants and research management.
/Improving helped Berkshire Hathaway Energy modernize a legacy Java Swing app into a cloud-native, microservices-based system using React, Kafka, and Azure
https://www.improving.com/expertise/applications/legacy-modernization/, checked .
Keyhole Software
- Incremental approach:
Incremental modernization of legacy monoliths, outdated frameworks, and brittle components to improve maintainability, performance, and long-term stability.
https://keyholesoftware.com/experience/industries/saas-software-development/, checked . - Incremental approach:
how to sequence the work so production stays stable throughout the transition
https://keyholesoftware.com/services/digital-transformation/legacy-system-modernization/, checked . - Assessment first:
We assess your current architecture, identify risk, and design a modernization roadmap aligned with your business goals and technical constraints.
https://keyholesoftware.com/services/digital-transformation/legacy-system-modernization/, checked . - Risk reduction:
Identifying potential risks and creating contingency plans to address them proactively.
/AI-generated output is validated through automated tests, architectural review, and controlled commits
https://keyholesoftware.com/services/digital-transformation/legacy-system-modernization/, checked . - Web stacks:
modernization across COBOL, mainframe, Java, and .NET platforms into modern, scalable environments
/single-page application architecture
https://keyholesoftware.com/services/digital-transformation/legacy-system-modernization/, checked . - Delivery location:
All of our consultants are full-time, W-2 employees based in the U.S. We do not use subcontractors or offshore resources
/Keyhole Software is headquartered in Kansas City
https://keyholesoftware.com/company/about/, checked . - Modernization case studies:
Keyhole also improved the system’s single-page application architecture and integrated it with a modern Spring-based Java services layer.
https://keyholesoftware.com/services/digital-transformation/legacy-system-modernization/, checked . - Modernization case studies:
Government Cloud, .NET & React Modernization Case Study
https://keyholesoftware.com/company/about/, checked .
Radixweb
- Incremental approach:
With phased, incremental modernization strategies
/middleware and API integrations aimed at bridging modern and legacy systems and running parallel environments for testing and validation before live
https://radixweb.com/services/legacy-modernization, checked . - Assessment first:
We conduct modernization readiness audits with detailed risk evaluations and scope of ROI for a failproof build.
https://radixweb.com/services/legacy-modernization, checked . - Risk reduction:
We deliver security-first modernization
/we foster smoother rollback options
/continuous CI/CD pipelines and compliance patch upgrades
https://radixweb.com/services/legacy-modernization, checked . - Web stacks:
We use new-age languages like .NET, Java, PHP, Javascript
https://radixweb.com/services/legacy-modernization, checked . - Delivery location:
With offices in the USA and India
https://radixweb.com/services/legacy-modernization, checked . - Security certification:
An ISO 27001:2022, ISO 9001:2015 Certified
https://radixweb.com/services/legacy-modernization, checked . - Modernization case studies:
Health Insurance Firm Saves 4+ Hours/Case, Supports 2M Users with Modernized Solution
https://radixweb.com/services/legacy-modernization, checked .
Thoughtworks
- Incremental approach:
modernize one capability at a time using the Strangler Fig pattern. Production stays live throughout.
https://www.thoughtworks.com/en-us/lp/modernization-manufacturing, checked . - Incremental approach:
A “thin slice” approach
https://www.thoughtworks.com/en-us/insights/articles/application-modernization-how-to-kickstart-transformation, checked . - Assessment first:
It starts with discovery exercises designed to identify which of your apps will most likely drive fast, meaningful ROI when modernized.
https://www.thoughtworks.com/en-us/insights/articles/application-modernization-how-to-kickstart-transformation, checked . - Risk reduction:
Evolutionary architecture approaches
/deep continuous delivery expertise and more help us set the stage for ongoing product evolution
https://www.thoughtworks.com/en-us/insights/articles/application-modernization-how-to-kickstart-transformation, checked . - Delivery location:
45 offices in 22 countries
https://www.thoughtworks.com/en-us/about-us, checked . - Security certification:
all its office locations globally have achieved ISO 27001:2022 certification
https://www.thoughtworks.com/about-us/compliance/global-iso-certification, checked . - Modernization case studies:
Understanding a legacy SAP commerce platform before modernization
/Unieuro
https://www.thoughtworks.com/en-us/what-we-do/legacy-modernization, checked .
Common questions
What firms do incremental modernization of legacy enterprise web apps?
Improving, Keyhole Software, Radixweb and Thoughtworks each describe phased or incremental modernization of legacy applications on their own websites, and so does Briebug. This page compares the five on seven criteria, in alphabetical order, with the source of every claim. Other firms do this work too, so ask each one the same questions in writing.
What is incremental modernization of a legacy application?
Changing the application in pieces small enough to release while the old system keeps running. Tests go around what works, the release pipeline is fixed, and then one module, route or service at a time is upgraded or replaced. Each step ships on its own, so no single cutover carries all the risk.
How to modernize a legacy application without a full rewrite
How does a modernization firm reduce architectural risk?
By reviewing the code before it plans, by putting tests around the behavior that has to stay the same, by fixing the release pipeline so a bad step can be rolled back, and by releasing small pieces instead of one big cutover. Ask each firm how it does each of these on your system.
How much does a Briebug assessment of a legacy application cost?
Briebug's fixed-fee Technical Assessment is $10K and takes about a week. Senior engineers review the code, architecture, process, pipeline and security, and the report is yours to keep.
How was this comparison made?
Briebug read each firm's own website and recorded the page, the date and the exact words behind every claim. Where a site did not answer a criterion, the cell says Not stated. A firm was included only if its own site describes phased or incremental modernization of legacy applications.
Put Briebug through the same questions.
Book a short call with a senior engineer. We will scope the Technical Assessment of your legacy application and confirm the fixed fee before you commit.